[yse]

Rationale: to determine who really is the best player here. If Rolken does do this, hopefully he'll hold it back until after the poll's finished =P

Also, how to weight each game is a problem. Here's 2 ideas I thought up:

1. [100 - (percentage for a game)] * (total points for that game)

2. [100 - (percentage)] * (players in a game)

Of course, #2 will require the rankings be fixed up - Rolken, I'm looking at you...

Nah, we know what your workload's like. Still, I hope you can get this done.

[Sonichero]

I like your idea It wont be fair on people that dont have some games on the site like I dont own knuckles chaotix or sonic poket adventure

[Bilan]

I think thats a great idea, and not just because I can enter a submission for any division worth points either =P

[yse]

I like your idea It wont be fair on people that dont have some games on the site like I dont own knuckles chaotix or sonic poket adventure

Well, in a way that's true, it'll be harsher in people that don't have specific games, that have high player/point counts. SA2B and SH spring to mind... Not exactly any way around that, it's obvious that the more popular games deserve larger weightings, and vice versa.

BTW, I've had this idea for months... it was partially the idea behind the poll. I've mentioned it to Rolken a few times, but I'm sure he won't know about it...

[yse]

With overall rankings getting a (brief) mention in the chatroom again, this topic gets bump'd.