I asked him to show me his route last time I saw him, and he managed a 1:0x:xx, claiming he screwed up, but usually gets 44's using that route. I then tried this route and the best I could pull off was around 52, meaning there is no way he got his 44:42, and when you consider that his previous time was fake, along with his Hot Crater Act 1 time, it becomes kind of obvious that his times are lies and should be removed.
EDIT: Leaf Forest Act 2- Cream- 0:43:97....PWNED!